Who do you call when a company is facing a reputation crisis? One person who can make decisions with you inside the first hour, usually a crisis communications consultant, with your lawyer on the same call if there is legal exposure, and nobody else until the facts are straight. That is the work The PR Bunker does for companies in Boston and across Massachusetts: a crisis communications consultant who builds the 15 to 30 minute response before the phone rings, so the first hour is spent deciding who speaks and who hears it first instead of shopping for help. The rest of this page walks the first 48 hours, hour by hour.
Key Takeaways
When something goes sideways, your instinct is to call everyone, and that's the first mistake. You want one person on the phone who has been through this before, who can help you think clearly, and who will tell you the truth even when it's uncomfortable. For most small and midsize companies that's a crisis communications or reputation management consultant, and if there's any chance of legal exposure, your attorney is on the same call from the start so you aren't playing telephone between the two of them.
I spent years as a reporter before I got into strategic communications, so I've been on the other end of the call when a company is in trouble. The ones that came through it well almost always had a small, calm group making decisions fast. The ones that made it worse had too many cooks, a CEO who wanted to fight it out in public, or nobody willing to make a call at all.
If you're a small company, you probably don't have a communications director on staff, and that's normal. What you need is someone you can reach at 9 p.m. on a Friday who already understands your business, which is a lot easier if you found that person before the crisis and not during it.
Your only job in the first two hours is to understand what actually happened. Who was involved, what do you know for certain, what are you still guessing at, and who outside the company already knows? Write it down in one place, and keep the facts you've confirmed separate from the rumors you've heard.
Lock down who speaks for the company. Tell your staff, plainly and quickly, that one person handles all outside questions and that nobody else posts, comments or replies to anything. This sounds obvious, and it's still the step that gets skipped most, which is how a well-meaning employee ends up as the source in the first story.
You don't need the whole story to say something. A holding statement acknowledges what's happening, says what you're doing about it and tells people when they'll hear from you next, and it does all of that without guessing, blaming or promising things you can't deliver.
The point of our post "Silence Isn't Neutral" is that saying nothing doesn't keep you out of the story. It hands the story to whoever is willing to talk, and that's rarely the person with the best information. A short, honest statement now is worth more than a polished one tomorrow.
Before the public hears anything else, the people closest to you should hear it from you. That's usually your employees first, then your key customers, partners, board members or funders, and then the broader public and the press. Each group gets a version that's honest and fitted to what they need to know, and every version has to match, because people compare notes faster than you think.
If reporters are calling, call them back. You don't have to give them everything, but you do have to treat them like professionals with a deadline, because they are. Give them the facts you've confirmed, tell them when you'll know more and then follow through on that promise.
By day two you'll start seeing what stuck, including the parts that are wrong. Correct factual errors quickly and politely, with the source directly, and don't pick fights over tone or opinion because you won't win those.
This is also when you need to check what AI assistants are saying about you. Reputation management has moved from search rankings to what assistants like ChatGPT and Google's AI answers say when someone asks about your company, a shift that firms such as Reputation and Status Labs have been publishing about throughout 2026. If an assistant is summarizing the worst version of your story, that summary is what a prospective customer will read first. Getting accurate, updated information out on your own site and in credible outside sources is how you start to change what those tools say.
Here's the part nobody wants to hear in the middle of a crisis. How it ends was mostly decided before it started. Ragan ran a piece in August 2026 titled "AI won't predict your next crisis, but it can absolutely help you prepare for one," featuring Danielle Grossman of the Houston Livestock Show and Rodeo, and the theme running through that conversation is the same one I've seen for 25 years, which is that the trust you built before the crisis decides the outcome.
That's the whole point of our post "Reputation Is a Line Item," which makes the case that reputation work belongs in the budget every year and not just in the emergency fund. Companies that already have relationships with their community, their customers and the local press get the benefit of the doubt. Companies that show up for the first time in the middle of a mess don't.
If you're reading this before anything has gone wrong, that's the best time to pick who you'd call. If you're reading it at 11 p.m. with your phone buzzing, start at hour zero and get the facts.
Who do you call when a company is facing a reputation crisis? One person who can make decisions with you inside the first hour, usually a crisis communications consultant who has been through it before, with your attorney on the same call if there is legal exposure. Everyone else, including the press, waits until the facts are confirmed and one spokesperson is named. In Boston, The PR Bunker is that first call, with a 15 to 30 minute response framework built before the crisis starts.
Who should a small company call first in a reputation crisis? Call a crisis communications or reputation management consultant who can help you make decisions quickly, and bring your attorney onto the same call if there's any legal exposure.
What should a company do in the first 48 hours of a crisis? Confirm the facts in the first two hours, issue a short holding statement within about six hours, brief employees and key stakeholders before the public, and use day two to correct errors and check what AI assistants are saying about you.
Should a company stay silent during a crisis? Usually not. Silence lets other people define the story, so a short, honest holding statement is almost always better than saying nothing.
How does AI affect reputation management during a crisis? Customers, donors and residents now ask AI assistants about a company before they ask a colleague, so you need to check what those tools are saying and put accurate, current information where they can find it.
If you want someone in your corner before the phone starts ringing, book a strategy call.
Related: Crisis communications consultant in Boston, the service page, and When the Storm Hits: How Reputation Decides the Outcome, on the pre-crisis checklist.
Have a project, campaign, or comms challenge in mind?
Want to be a guest on the PR Bunker podcast?
Reach out and let’s talk.
