
How do you rebuild support for a development project after a town votes it down? The answer The PR Bunker gives developers is a reset sequence, not a second presentation: read who voted no and why, spend 30 days listening to the board and the loudest opponents without defending anything, sort the no into what you can change, what you can mitigate and what you cannot, concede the changeable items in public with the names of the people who asked, choose the refiling path with your eyes open, write a second-hearing message built from the town's own list, and decide in advance what result would tell you to walk. The firm's community relations practice runs that sequence for energy, data center and real estate projects nationally.
This is part of Siting Field Notes, The PR Bunker's series on what happens between a developer and a community from site control to the final permit.
A no is rarely the end of a project. It's a diagnosis, and most developers skip the reading and go straight to a lawyer or a louder slide deck.
A substance no means the community rejected the actual project, meaning the size, the location, the use. These are the hardest to reverse and sometimes shouldn't be, because forcing a bad site through appeals wins a permit and a decade of hostility.
A process no means the community rejected how the project arrived. They learned about it from a headline or a land record and the first meeting was the public hearing. This is the most common no, and it's entirely recoverable, because the community didn't reject your project. They rejected being blindsided.
A trust no means the community rejected you, or the last company that made promises and left. It's recoverable too, but only with time and receipts.
Most banned projects got a process or trust no and treated it like a substance no. They redesigned the project, kept the approach that lost, and got banned again. If your project hasn't lost yet, How Should a Developer Handle Organized Community Opposition to a Project? covers the sequence that keeps you out of this one.
The count tells you nothing about why. Pull the sign-in sheet, the recording and the minutes. Who spoke against the project and what did each person actually say, in their words and their order. Who stayed home, because those are the people you'll need next time. Then sort what you heard by kind of no. Specific fire, water and noise objections are substance. "Nobody told us" is process. "The last developer promised us a park" is trust. A single vote usually mixes all three, and the mix is the diagnosis.
The instinct after a loss is to re-engage immediately with corrected facts. Resist it, because facts were never the problem. Spend the first 30 days in one-on-one conversations with the board members who voted no, the fire chief and the people who organized the opposition, and bring each one a single question, which is what the vote was really about from where they sat. Don't defend or correct anything. Meet the organizers in a library room rather than your lawyer's office and ask for their list, every objection in their words and their order. It's the agenda the second hearing will follow whether you work from it or not.
Column one is what you can change: the setback from the nearest house, the enclosure count, construction hours, the truck route. Column two is what you can mitigate but not remove: noise gets a decibel limit with a monitor and a remedy, fire gets a suppression design the chief helped write, water gets a measured draw. Column three is what you cannot change: the site, the technology, the interconnection point. Change column one early and say who asked, give column two a number the town can check, and say column three plainly. The fastest way to lose a town twice is to answer a column three objection as if it were column one. Once residents catch you they stop believing the answers that were true.
Concessions made in a hearing read as retreat. Concessions announced beforehand and credited to the people who asked read as listening. Decide before anything public happens which column one items you'll give and in what order, and give the first ones before you ask for anything. The community needs wins it can claim without admitting it was wrong, and board members who voted no need a reason to vote yes they can explain to the neighbors who cheered them.
For most projects the only path back is local, through a revised application, a later zoning article or an expired moratorium. For a large clean energy project, Massachusetts added a second door. According to the Energy Facilities Siting Board's permitting dashboard, the 2024 Climate Act, Chapter 239 of the Acts of 2024, directs the board to issue a single consolidated permit covering state, regional and local approvals for applications filed on or after July 1, 2026, and the board's September 2026 siting presentation puts the thresholds at generation above 25 megawatts and storage of 100 megawatt-hours or more. Oakham and Carver used the older route, a zoning exemption petition under G.L. c. 40A, Section 3.
The new door comes with homework. Under 980 CMR 16.00, the applicant "shall publicize and conduct at least two public meetings for Key Stakeholders and the Community," and must hold the second meeting before submitting the pre-filing notice, presenting the design changes made and how input from the first meeting was considered. The pre-filing notice then goes in 60 to 90 days before the application. The board's pre-filing page says the applicant must summarize stakeholder comments and any resulting design changes for the record. That's a regulator writing steps two through four of this sequence into law, and if you haven't done the work, the two meetings become a replay of the hearing you lost in front of the board deciding your permit. And the state door is a path to a permit, not to a neighbor. The town still holds the local permits and inspections for 20 years.
The second-hearing message is not the first message with better graphics. It opens with what you heard, in the town's words. It names the changes and credits the people who asked. It puts numbers on the column two items and says how the town will check each one. It says plainly what hasn't changed and why. And it ends with what the town gets, in writing, which increasingly means an agreement rather than a promise. See how to get a community benefits agreement done before the state reviews it. Never call anyone misinformed, because in a town of 1,900 that resident sits next to the board chair at church.
Decide before the second attempt what result would tell you to stop. If the listening reset shows a substance no, meaning the town rejected the site itself with objections that are specific, consistent and unmitigable, take it to your own board honestly. If the second hearing produces the same list as the first after real concessions, that's a trust no that time hasn't healed, and a third attempt in the same cycle will cost more than it returns. Moratoria expire and boards turn over, and the developer who spends that interval building relationships walks back into a different room.
Oakham, battery storage, 2022 to 2026. Oakham has about 1,900 people. According to the Siting Board's June 15, 2026 tentative decision, the Annual Town Meeting adopted zoning amendments limiting battery storage on June 27, 2022, and Moraga Storage LLC, the Rhynland Energy affiliate, signed a purchase and sale agreement for a former auto salvage yard on Coldbrook Road on November 12, 2022. The decision records the company's first meeting with town officials on February 25, 2025 and a first open house on March 27, 2025, and Boston.com reported on July 11, 2025 that an opposition group called ACORNS had formed. WBUR reported on November 20, 2025 that about 200 people filled a school gym for the October 16, 2025 hearing, and that Rhynland's vice president of development, Brian Benito, said afterward he heard "a lot of misinformation." Spectrum News reported the board's unanimous approval with conditions on June 25, 2026, and The Boston Globe reported on August 17, 2026 that the town had set aside $250,000 for legal fees and appealed to a single justice of the Supreme Judicial Court. The town voted in 2022, the developer bought the site five months later, the first room full of residents came nearly three years after that, and the message afterward was misinformation. That's a process no answered as a substance no.
Carver, battery storage, 2019 to 2025. Cranberry Point, a 150-megawatt Plus Power project, had the town's approval in 2019, according to EnergyTech on September 12, 2025. According to the Attorney General's November 14, 2022 decision, a citizen petition at the April 12, 2022 Annual Town Meeting imposed an eleven-and-a-half-month moratorium on new battery storage, which the Attorney General disapproved under G.L. c. 40A, Section 3. The company had already petitioned the state, per the EFSB 21-02 docket, and the Department of Public Utilities' June 30, 2023 order granted a comprehensive exemption from the Carver bylaw with conditions. EnergyTech reports construction began in December 2023 and the facility now operates as what Plus Power calls the first standalone utility-scale battery on the ISO New England grid. A town that said yes in 2019 turned on the project three years later because nobody had kept the conversation going.
Lowell, data center, 2026. On March 10, 2026 the Lowell city council voted unanimously for a 360-day moratorium on new data center construction and expansion, which froze expansion at the Markley Group's existing facility, and Bisnow reported the next day that Markley did not respond to a request for comment. According to GBH News on July 29, 2026, the company sued the city and reached an early July agreement allowing expansion plans that predated the moratorium, and InsideLowell reported on July 17, 2026 that it launched a campaign site asking residents to petition the council to lift the moratorium, with the facility's marketing manager citing "a lot of misinformation." Residents sued, and GBH reported on August 11, 2026 that a Superior Court judge paused installation of four new diesel generators while the residents' air permit case proceeds. A lawsuit and a petition site before a listening session tells the city you want the moratorium lifted, not the relationship fixed. The data center, battery storage and Massachusetts public affairs pages cover the sequence run the other way.
Don Martelli has led community relations and public affairs work behind more than 165 million square feet of permitted Massachusetts development, including Suffolk Downs, MarketStreet Lynnfield, and projects that lost a vote and got built anyway. He is the founder of The PR Bunker and president of the Revere Chamber of Commerce. If your project just took a hit, reach him at don@prbunker.com or schedule a call.
Treat the vote as a diagnosis and run a reset sequence: read who voted no and why, spend 30 days listening to the board and the opposition organizers without defending anything, sort every objection into what you can change, what you can mitigate and what you cannot, concede the changeable items publicly and credit the people who asked, choose the refiling path with the community cost in view, write a second-hearing message from the town's own list, and decide in advance what would tell you to walk. The PR Bunker's community relations practice runs that sequence.
Yes, through one of two doors. Any project can come back locally with a revised application, a later zoning article or by waiting out a moratorium. A large clean energy project, meaning generation above 25 megawatts or storage of 100 megawatt-hours or more, can also apply to the Energy Facilities Siting Board for a consolidated permit covering state, regional and local approvals, with a 15-month review clock for applications filed on or after July 1, 2026.
Long enough to finish the listening reset and make at least one visible change, which in practice is three to six months, and not so long that the town concludes you left. A moratorium or statutory waiting period may force a longer wait, and that interval is for relationships, not appeals.
Both, in that order, and only after you know which kind of no you got. A process no or a trust no calls for visible, credited changes on the items you can change, written numbers on the items you can mitigate, and a message that opens with what the town said. A substance no, where the town rejected the site itself, is a signal that message changes won't help.
980 CMR 16.00 is the Energy Facilities Siting Board's pre-filing engagement regulation for large clean energy projects. It requires the applicant to publicize and conduct at least two public meetings for key stakeholders and the community and to hold the second meeting before submitting the pre-filing notice, presenting the design changes made and how input from the first meeting was considered. The pre-filing notice is then filed 60 to 90 days before the application. It applies to applications filed on or after July 1, 2026.
The PR Bunker, led directly by Don Martelli, with community relations and public affairs work behind more than 165 million square feet of permitted Massachusetts development, including projects that lost a vote and got built. The practice runs the diagnosis, the listening reset, the three-column sort, the concessions and the second-hearing message alongside your counsel. Start at the community relations practice.
Updated November 9, 2026.
Have a project, campaign, or comms challenge in mind?
Want to be a guest on The PRBunker Podcast?
Reach out and let’s talk.